What I'm Seeing Now

head_left_image

You Have To See Everything Because A Thermal Image Alone Can Fool You

You have to see everything because a thermal image alone can fool you.

It wasn't a cold day out, about 45F.  And it was cloudy.

Breaking out Mighty Mo to do the thermal image sweep of the insulation in the house, this is what the ceilings looked like on the upper level.

The roof rafter joists are visible as the purple lines, with the insulation filling the gap between.

The temperature difference between the insulated areas and the wood joist rafters is not very different.

Does this appear to be a well-insulated space?

To know for sure you have to look into the attic space!

Does that look like a good amount of insulation?

It is not.

This house was built in 1954 and the original insulation was a thin layer of mineral wool typical of the era.

While mineral wool is a very good insulator, this thin layer does not provide much of a thermal barrier, with little R-value.

The tops of the roof joist rafters can be seen.

On top of the mineral wool the homeowner at some point laid a layer of cardboard down, ostensibly to improve the insulation in the attic.  When I don't know, but there was newspaper on top of the cardboard dated 1980, so apparently the cardboard preceded that.

However, from the thermal image alone one might think the insulation was plentiful and well placed.

Instead we found a consistent thin layer of mineral wool with cardboard on top.

What is the thermal R-value of cardboard?  About .25.

My recommendation:  thermal imaging requires that one look at the big picture.  All of the facts must be investigated to help determine if the thermal image seen is the complete picture.   Moisture cannot be determined without a moisture meter.  Missing insulation cannot be determined unless one looks at what is happening on the other side.  And so it is with this attic space.  While the thermal image looks to be consistent and perhaps indicating good insulation, the fact is that the image is simply reporting a consistent layer of covering.  I expect in very cold weather these rooms are cold and in very hot weather these rooms are uncomfortably warm because the insulation above is not very good!

 

 

Jay Markanich Real Estate Inspections, LLC  

Based in Bristow, serving all of Northern Virginia.

Office (703) 330-6388   Cell (703) 585-7560

www.jaymarinspect.com


Comment balloon 7 commentsJay Markanich • February 07 2017 12:07PM
You Have To See Everything Because A Thermal Image Alone Can Fool You
share
You have to see everything because a thermal image alone can fool you. It wasn't a cold day out, about 45F. And it was cloudy. Breaking out Mighty Mo to do the thermal image sweep of the insulation in the house, this is what the ceilings looked… more
"The Code Has Changed Since We Installed That. " Um, Not…
share
"The code has changed since we installed that. " Um, not… Stopping by a house I had inspected a couple of days prior, the seller met me to let me in to retrieve a radon device. This seller thought I was there to look at and repair the… more
"It's Too Cold To Paint… "
share
"It's too cold to paint… " Paint has a particular chemistry - indoor and outdoor paint. It has temperature and humidity parameters that must be met or it will not adhere or last. I arrived at a home inspection early, as I am wont to do,… more
The Term "Duct Tape" Is A Misnomer
share
The term duct tape is a misnomer. But how can that be? Duct tape has been around forever! I have a wonderful book in my library called, Did Monkeys Invent the Monkey Wrench? It is a fun history book of tools and hardware information. In my version… more
Metal HVAC Ducts Are Famously Leaky
share
Metal HVAC ducts are famously leaky. Metal HVAC ducts leak air. Metal HVAC ducts leak energy. Metal HVAC ducts leak money! One example is shown in the photo to the right. This is a duct in a house built in 1979. The seams in the photo have been… more
And A River Ran Through It - The House, That Is
share
And a river ran through it - the house, that is. Inspecting a crawl space, as I am wont to do, the dirt floor was completely covered with thick, black plastic. That's good! The underside of the floor was insulated. That's good! The ventilation… more
When The Water Heater Gets Buried Behind A Wall
share
When the water heater gets buried behind a wall. How can the water heater be removed? What to do!? Four years ago the kitchen was remodeled and a new water heater and furnace were put into the original closet in this house. This installation… more
Unprofessional Plumbing Work
share
What I saw was unprofessional plumbing work. The phone call said that a contractor (in the carpet industry) said he also did remodeling on the side and completely reworked two bathrooms. The plumber that was sent was unfamiliar with the work he was… more
"When We Sit Near Our Fireplace It's Really Cold Unless We Turn…
share
"When we sit near our fireplace it's really cold unless we turn it on. " You go to watch "the game" or a movie and sit down next to the fireplace. And everyone needs a blanket! That or the fireplace has to be turned on to feel… more
Can Pressure-Treated Deck Wood Rot?
share
Can pressure-treated deck wood rot? In short, the answer is yes. Given enough time pressure-treated wood, even that rated for ground contact, will deteriorate and rot. The bases of every post of this deck had rotted. My pen is sticking into this one… more